top of page

Quit Whining (part II)

10 minutes ago
3 min read

By John Phillips


Whining? Well, that is probably too extreme, but I wanted to get your attention. 


Most of my professional experience has not been in the construction industry, and so much of the information I have accumulated has come to me relatively recently (often from Linkedin posts). We all celebrate off site construction, there seem to be significant advantages using it, but there is an undertone of frustration: why doesn’t it have a bigger presence in the construction industry? That was the subject of a previous article  – Quit Whining (part I). This is Part II.



Modular construction takes place in a facility “off site”, meaning not where the building will be located.  Those not part of the sector would call these manufacturing facilities, but because the term “manufactured” has a specific meaning inside the industry, they usually aren’t referred to that way. Which to the uninitiated, like me, immediately gives us something to whine about: it takes away an easy way to describe the industry. Regardless, this is a drastically different method of construction and brings with a totally different business perspective and is the source of the “whining”. The fact that the buildings are built off site is a comment worthy of “duh”, but the issues this creates are significant.


Ignoring the terminology used in the industry, modular facilities are manufacturing plants, and operate very differently than site building. Although the end products are very similar, the processes used to produce them are very different. This is no surprise, of course. Modular companies are populated with people who built buildings the traditional way. The manufacturing world is foreign to them. As a result, it is easy to whine about it. I am looking at you, Gary Fleisher https://offsiteinnovators.com/, with a smile on my face (Gary is a highly experienced and insightful observer of the modular sector; I learn a lot from his Linkedin posts). I refer to it as whining but it involves normal business for manufacturing companies but is amplified in the off site construction sector.


There are two general aspects to this.


Internal


My assumption is that the individuals who start and operate modular plants are competent builders and think that skill translate into off site construction. They are correct, of course, and the products they produce are quality. But they are inexperienced in the dynamics of manufacturing: materials management, staffing and training, through put, capital requirements, technical improvements, and on and on. A whole new ballgame; a totally different ballgame than site construction. A few legacy builders, like Clayton and Champion, understand these challenges, but are whine worthy for other reasons. See below


External


This applies to the big companies, maybe even more than the smaller guys. It is my understanding that the modular industry developed out of the mobile home industry, and relied on a dealer network to deliver their products to the end customer. It was business to business and didn’t have a relationship with the ultimate customers, at least not like many manufacturers have (think automobile manufacturers, appliance companies, etc.). I doubt many home buyers can name modular companies. Home builders are constantly in front of potential buyers, modular builders are not. The modular sector does not have good downstream communication channels. No wonder they have difficulty expanding their market share. This is not only communication to the buyers, but with the whole real estate ecosystem: real estate agents, finance, governments, etc.


Modular is manufacturing not just construction. Factories in all industries fail; if any of the key elements of success are ignored, they fail.


So what to do about it? Learn what works. Implement it. And be patient. These things take time.

Comments


bottom of page